Introduction. The resting energy expenditure (REE) represents the largest component of total daily energy expenditure. Estimating REE is of utmost importance for targeted interventions in obese people. Indirect calorimetry (IC) is the gold standard for the measurement of REE but it is a complex procedure, therefore prediction equations are often used in clinical practice. Recently, a portable multisensor (SenseWear Armband, SWA) has been proposed, as an alternative to IC for the measurement of REE, however the few existing works on the validity of this method for the measurement of REE have provided apparently controversial results. The study aims are: 1) to validate the accuracy of the SWA versus IC as a means for the estimate of REE; 2) to assess the most appropriate method for the use of SWA; 3) to evaluate whether the use of SWA provides advantages as compared to the equations. Subjects and methods. The study was conducted on 57 patients with diabetes mellitus type 2 average age and IMC were 60 ± 5.3 years and 30 ± 5 kg/m 2. In 57 type 2 diabetic patients REE was measured by IC and with SWA using three recording methods: 1) "SWA without acclimatisation" (i.e. simultaneously with CI analyzing the whole recording period); 2) "SWA with acclimatisation" (i.e. simultaneously with CI, but discarding from analysis the first 10 minutes to allow for the adaptation of the sensors to the environmental conditions); 3) "SWA night" (i.e. using the average recordings of 10 minutes prior awakening for three consecutive nights). The REE was also estimated by the prediction equation of Harris-Benedict and Mifflin. Data analysis was conducted by paired t-test and Pearson correlation, furthermore the percent difference (Δ% or bias %) of each value against IC was calculated. The REE estimate provided by "SWA with acclimatisation" is very similar at the REE estimated with the Mifflin equation. Results. For all methods, the estimated values of REE are significantly correlated with the IC. On average REE measured by "SWA without adaptation" and "SWA night" was significantly higher than with IC (respectively 1590 ± 336 and 1512 ± 214 vs 1455 ± 221 kcal/day; p < 0.05), whereas REE measured by "SWA with adaptation" is very similar to the value obtained by IC (1469 ± 193 vs 1455 ± 221 kcal/day; p = ns). Of the 3 recording methods "SWA with adaptation" has the lowest bias % as compared to IC. As for the predictive equations Harris-Benedict's, but not Mifflin's significantly overestimates REE (respectively 1545 " 201 e 1466 " 209 vs 1455 " 221 kcal/day), accordingly the bias % is 7,3% for Harris-Benedict, and only 1,3% for Mifflin. Discussion. Our results indicate that the SWA can be effectively used for the measurement of REE; the most appropriate mode of use is "with adaptation"; the use of SWA does not provide substantial advantage over Mifflin's formula.
Validation of a new portable device for the measurement of resting energy expenditure in patients with type 2 diabetes mellitus
Massimino E.;
2009-01-01
Abstract
Introduction. The resting energy expenditure (REE) represents the largest component of total daily energy expenditure. Estimating REE is of utmost importance for targeted interventions in obese people. Indirect calorimetry (IC) is the gold standard for the measurement of REE but it is a complex procedure, therefore prediction equations are often used in clinical practice. Recently, a portable multisensor (SenseWear Armband, SWA) has been proposed, as an alternative to IC for the measurement of REE, however the few existing works on the validity of this method for the measurement of REE have provided apparently controversial results. The study aims are: 1) to validate the accuracy of the SWA versus IC as a means for the estimate of REE; 2) to assess the most appropriate method for the use of SWA; 3) to evaluate whether the use of SWA provides advantages as compared to the equations. Subjects and methods. The study was conducted on 57 patients with diabetes mellitus type 2 average age and IMC were 60 ± 5.3 years and 30 ± 5 kg/m 2. In 57 type 2 diabetic patients REE was measured by IC and with SWA using three recording methods: 1) "SWA without acclimatisation" (i.e. simultaneously with CI analyzing the whole recording period); 2) "SWA with acclimatisation" (i.e. simultaneously with CI, but discarding from analysis the first 10 minutes to allow for the adaptation of the sensors to the environmental conditions); 3) "SWA night" (i.e. using the average recordings of 10 minutes prior awakening for three consecutive nights). The REE was also estimated by the prediction equation of Harris-Benedict and Mifflin. Data analysis was conducted by paired t-test and Pearson correlation, furthermore the percent difference (Δ% or bias %) of each value against IC was calculated. The REE estimate provided by "SWA with acclimatisation" is very similar at the REE estimated with the Mifflin equation. Results. For all methods, the estimated values of REE are significantly correlated with the IC. On average REE measured by "SWA without adaptation" and "SWA night" was significantly higher than with IC (respectively 1590 ± 336 and 1512 ± 214 vs 1455 ± 221 kcal/day; p < 0.05), whereas REE measured by "SWA with adaptation" is very similar to the value obtained by IC (1469 ± 193 vs 1455 ± 221 kcal/day; p = ns). Of the 3 recording methods "SWA with adaptation" has the lowest bias % as compared to IC. As for the predictive equations Harris-Benedict's, but not Mifflin's significantly overestimates REE (respectively 1545 " 201 e 1466 " 209 vs 1455 " 221 kcal/day), accordingly the bias % is 7,3% for Harris-Benedict, and only 1,3% for Mifflin. Discussion. Our results indicate that the SWA can be effectively used for the measurement of REE; the most appropriate mode of use is "with adaptation"; the use of SWA does not provide substantial advantage over Mifflin's formula.I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.


